Dear Gabor:

Thanks for providing authors responses to the referee reports. I note that you did not choose to respond to the discussion comment by the lead-author of the original paper?

I am not sure that you have suggested or enacted revisions to your comment paper itself in response to the referee report, so I have categorized the paper as 'publish subject to minor revisions' (further review by me) to give you the chance, should you wish, to incorporate the elements of the discussion that you and the referee agree on and upload a final version of the paper that you want to appear in the journal. Please confine any changes in the final version to be consistent with the minor changes suggested by the referee.

Note anyway that if you choose not to take this opportunity (let me know), the referee report and your response (and all manuscript versions) will be published when I accept the paper. In addition, I understand that, as is traditional for comment papers, the original authors will be offered the right of publishing a reply, so something similar to their online comment may well appear in the journal anyway.

I hope the way forward is clear, let me know if you have questions.

Best wishes, Chris.

Dear Gabor:

Thanks for uploading the revised comment. I accept the comment.

Best wishes, Chris