Dear Authors,

thank you for the provided replies to the discussion phase. The replies are sufficient, but may not satisfy an acceptance. Thus, the manuscript is subject to another review by by a referee and the editor.

The editor noted that some statements in the replies are a bit too ambitious regarding the novelty of the findings as similar aspects are already reported for tidal winds.

The suggestion of the referees to expand the introduction and the discussion of the results in a broader context appears to the editor a justified comment.

The editor kindly ask the authors to revise the manuscript and upload the this revised version for the further review process. As indicated by both referees the study is of high relevance and will become a significant contribution. In particular, if the results are discussed in a broader context and linked to other publications in the field that might be even beyond SABER observations.

Best regards,
Gunter Stober

Dear Authors,

thank you for submitting a revised manuscript and the replies to the reviewer comments.
The revised version is subject to a further review.

Best Regards,
Gunter

Dear Authors,

the editor is pleased to inform you that both reviewers recommend publication and the paper is accepted as is.

Best Regards,
Gunter Stober